The NRA and Gun Ownership as a Political Identity

As more mass shootings rob innocent Americans of their lives, to the point where we more or less forget about them as soon as they happen (seriously, we’re barely talking about the Thousand Oaks shooting anymore, and that was less than three weeks ago) unless they somehow top all the ones that have come before (in terms of death toll, or novelty of targets, or vulnerability and innocence of the victims), the political debate continues to be wrestled away from legal and medical experts by the NRA, the political arm of a vocal identity group who cling to their beliefs, their peers and, of course, their guns.

Americans have more guns per person than any other country in the world, ahead of former and current war zone countries like Serbia and Yemen (to be fair, advanced peaceful countries like Switzerland and Sweden are also on the list, although these countries have greater levels of training and regulation, including varying levels of compulsory military service). Combine America’s large population and very high rate of gun ownership, and you come to the conclusion that Americans own between one third and one half of all privately owned guns in the world.

But it’s not just the number of guns in the country that make gun owners an important political force; it’s also how they view themselves and their cause. Candidate Barack Obama was heavily criticized ten years ago for dismissing voters who “cling to guns or religion” (sidenote: if you’re gonna make an off-putting comment like that, at least go for the alliteration: “God and guns” has a much better ring to it), but his juxtaposition of those two categories was telling.  If religious individuals are America’s first protected class via their inclusion in the First Amendment of the US Constitution, gun owners could be argued to be the country’s second protected class due to the Second Amendment.  Yet, at the time of the Constitution’s writing, the country’s founders did not think of gun owners as a special group of people (or, necessarily, of gun ownership as an individual right). That came later.

**Social Science Detour (feel free to skip if you’re not into nerdy academic isht)**

There’s a term in political science called constructivism. I often teach it, despite the fact that I (and I’m convinced, most political scientists) don’t actually know what it means. Constructivism is a complicated concept, but in short, it claims that the political identities, actions and interactions that exist are not based on some simple, easy to identify factors such as desire for power or safety or wealth, as earlier theories predict. Rather, constructivists argue that the ways people view themselves and their groups and how they interact are based on complex, changing social processes that create or “construct” share ideas that determine the ways in which people view the world.

If that all sounds like esoteric nonsense, let’s give an example:  Why are the United States and Canada so friendly (Trump-Trudeau sparing notwithstanding) when they share a massive, largely undefended border?  Some social scientists will say is because the two countries rationally calculate that neither would benefit from a war, or that they selfishly believe that fighting would cost too much (wars are expensive, and would disrupt trade – President Trump prefers cheaper methods of disrupting trade, like Twitter).

While these factors are all true, they’re not really the reason why, on a day-to-day basis, American and Canadian leaders decide not to go to war. Rather, these leaders don’t actively make that decision at all: war is simply unthinkable between the two societies, because history and culture in both countries have developed an idea that we are similar, cooperative nations and societies – we’ve constructed a worldview of the US and Canada as friends.  This was not always the case: during the unimaginatively named War of 1812, British troops from Canada invaded the US and burned down the freaking White House (who would have thought that a war between the US, Britain and Canada would be anything but boring and polite?), and US-Canada tensions persisted for over a century before fading away.

**Social Science Detour ended. You can wake up now.**

Gun owners in the US view themselves as a distinct group with an identity, camaraderie and interests.  This is not true of other countries: only a handful of them (some Latin American countries, as well as Liberia, the West African nation that was essentially founded as an American colony) have ever had a constitutional guarantee of the right to bear arms, and most have been repealed.  The existence of a significant gun owner identity was also not true of the US for most of its history. The founding fathers surely didn’t think of gun owners as a distinct group from non-gun owners – guns were a tool to fight off the British and whatnot, not something that made you a different type of person than your neighbor.

Lots of things go into social construction of identity: interactions, explicit ideals and philosophies, laws, rules and institutions, etc. The “gun owner” identity evolved and changed in several ways.  For much of US history, while the right to own firearms didn’t constitute its own identity, it was tied to white identity, as black Americans were often prohibited from owning guns. In the 1970s, in the context of both greater federal gun control measures and public cynicism toward government after Vietnam and Watergate, a fairly radical group within the National Rifle Association transformed the organization from a hobby group to a powerful lobby (as detailed in an excellent piece by Vox).

It was these efforts that reframed gun rights from a collective to individual right. It wasn’t until 2008 that the US Supreme Court, after decades of judges being influenced by the NRA’s interpretation of gun rights, definitively ruled that the Second Amendment granted an individual right to bear arms (think about it this way: The Big Bang Theory is older than the individual gun rights interpretation of the second amendment).

In the process, the NRA and those influenced by its ideology convinced gun owners that they were not just people with a shared leisure activity, but a distinct group, and an important one at that (as they potentially served as the last line of defense against tyrannical government). Today, American gun owners view the right to bear arms as an essential part of freedom (74% of gun owners share this view, compared to only 35% of non-gun owners who believe that gun owner rights are essential to freedom).

Gun ownership as an identity doesn’t just mean that gun owners place a lot of importance on that particular issue. It means that they are fundamentally different than non-gun owners in identifiable ways.  Three maps highlight this difference well.

The first map is the 2016 Presidential Election map.  The second and third maps, via SurveyMonkey, take that original map and split it into gun owners and non-gun owners, respectively.  In other words, if only the gun owners in each state had voted in 2016, Donald Trump would have won 49 states out of 50, while if only the non-gun owners of each state had voted, Hillary Clinton, would have won 47 states.  The world looks very different to Americans who own guns and those who do not.

It’s ironic that Donald Trump, far and away the choice of gun owners, is willing to point our guns toward our southern border to prevent immigrants and refugees from entering the US, especially those migrants from the countries to our immediate south, Mexico and Guatemala; these are the only two other countries in the world that protect gun ownership in their constitutions. What could be more American than that?

138 thoughts on “The NRA and Gun Ownership as a Political Identity”

  1. I?m impressed, I must say. Really rarely do I encounter a blog that?s both educative and entertaining, and let me tell you, you have hit the nail on the head. Your idea is outstanding; the issue is something that not enough people are speaking intelligently about. I am very happy that I stumbled across this in my search for something relating to this.

  2. 齐达内表示,反皇马主义一直都存在,但是问题是,支持皇马的皇马主义者现在越来越多,因为皇马是世界上最好的俱乐部,拥有最多的球迷,而且球迷数量每天都在增加。

  3. 香港明报报导,德国世界杯随着意大利击败法国而曲终人散,然而决赛延长赛下半场,法国球王席丹突然向意大利后卫(马特拉吉)施展(铁头功)导致被…意大利足球队后卫马特拉吉今天否认报导所说,他在周日世足决赛遭法国队长席丹以头锤顶撞倒地之前,曾将席丹(齐达内)称为“卑鄙的恐怖份子”。

  4. Youre so cool! I dont suppose Ive read anything like this before. So nice to find somebody with some original thoughts on this subject. realy thank you for starting this up. this website is something that is needed on the web, someone with a little originality. useful job for bringing something new to the internet!

  5. Nice post. I learn something more challenging on different blogs everyday. It will always be stimulating to read content from other writers and practice a little something from their store. I?d prefer to use some with the content on my blog whether you don?t mind. Natually I?ll give you a link on your web blog. Thanks for sharing.

  6. “der as fans sneak into stadiumSHAW NO CERTAINTYGareth Southgate tells Luke Shaw he must start playing for Manchester United to regain England spotKylian Me SoftlySergio Ramos tells Kylian Mbappe he is welcome at Real Madrid ahead of France vs Spain friendlyRAHEEM RECOVERYRaheem Sterling is fit for Manchester City's crunch Premier League clash at Arsenal#pogdaddyLoving son Paul Pogba visits dad Fassou Antoine in hospital to celebrate his 79th birthday after Frenchman is ruled out of Spain friendly through injuryFeeling smallInjured Chris Smalling looks down in the dumps after limping away from restaurant with his leg brace onHit the Gym, JackGareth Southgate warns Jack Wilshere to prove his fitness if he wants to win back an England spotCHILLINGNo time for cold feet as SunSport visit Fulham's training ground for a spot of cryotherapy treatmentICE COOL KIDJermain Defoe reveals cryotherapy chamber sessions are helping him stay young but his mum is ruining vegan diet by serving up meatUNITED RANT BOYSPolice are investigating Manchester United fans for homophobic chanting at ChelseaZaha had 'no passion'Gareth Southgate sensationally claims Wilfried Zaha did not have the heart to play for Englandlucky alliDele Alli cringed when he saw Neil Taylor's horror foul on Seamus Coleman and admits relief his tackle in Gent game didn't turn out same way'i cried when boro went down'Middlesbrough defender Ben Gibson knows better than anybody what relegation would mean for boyhood clubReds want Sak loadLiverpool outcast Mamadou Sakho wanted by Southampton and Napoli this summerEIGHT IS ENOUGHGareth Southgate holds crisis talks with Ross Barkley after seventh consecutive England snubHART DOES IT FOR KICKSJoe Hart is just as good with his kicking as the Prem's No1 sweeper-keeper Hugo LlorisBEAUTIFUL SIDE OF THE GAMEHeart-wrenching story of how brave Bradley Lowery, 5, struck up bond with 'best pal' Jermain Defoe as he battles cancer'I love him so much'Jermain Defoe has 'special bond' with 'best mate' Bradley Lowery, 5, as young Sunderland fan's parents spill beans on friendshiphere for keepsClaudio Bravo insists he‘s not quitting Man City after one calamitous season despite being dropped A Real statement read:?The medical services of Real Madrid have decided that our player Gareth Bale with have an operation as a consequence of the injury to the peroneal tendons of his right ankle.”

  7. 齐达内带领皇马在主场5-0大胜拉科鲁尼亚,法国人执教皇马首秀堪称完美;凭借梅西的“帽子戏法”以及内马尔的进球,巴塞罗那在主场4-0击败格拉纳达;马德里竞技在客场2-0力克塞尔塔,取得三连胜。

  8. I?m impressed, I must say. Really rarely do I encounter a blog that?s both educative and entertaining, and let me tell you, you have hit the nail on the head. Your idea is outstanding; the issue is something that not enough people are speaking intelligently about. I am very happy that I stumbled across this in my search for something relating to this.

  9. I discovered your blog site on google and check a few of your early posts. Continue to keep up the very good operate. I just additional up your RSS feed to my MSN News Reader. Seeking forward to reading more from you later on!?

  10. 齐达内执教首场比赛中可以看出,皇马球员做出了改变,仿佛换了一支球队,球员们在进攻端不仅踢的轻松、自由,在防守端也十分卖命,C罗与贝尔都会经常回撤到禁区参与球队的防守。

  11. 英国首席唇语专家今天表示,世足决赛中拿红牌被罚出场的法国中场球星席丹,是因意大利后卫马特拉吉骂他“恐怖份子骚货的儿子”,才愤而头槌攻击马…法国足球明星席丹在世足赛决赛的红牌事件继续受到广泛讨论,最新民调指出,61%法国民众原谅席丹犯规,52%表示理解。

  12. 同样身为联合国开发计划署亲善大使的前法国国家队队长齐达内(ZinedineZidane)和巴西传奇前锋罗纳尔多(Ronaldo),将和效力于英格兰超级足球联赛劲旅切尔西(Chelsea)的象牙海岸籍前锋“魔兽”德罗巴(DidierDrogba)、退役荷兰中场席多夫(ClarenceSeedorf)及前巴西国家队长卡富(Cafu)共同组队。

  13. 为什么皇马能够赢得欧冠,联赛却总是出问题?是不是欧冠对于球员们的动力更大?我觉得这也是不好解释的,因为皇马的目标永远是赢得一切冠军,今年我们再一次遇上了问题,这也是皇马这几年必然出现的情况,但是现在皇马已经从困境中出来了。

  14. Oh my goodness! an amazing article dude. Thank you However I am experiencing issue with ur rss . Don?t know why Unable to subscribe to it. Is there anyone getting identical rss problem? Anyone who knows kindly respond. Thnkx

  15. The next time I read a blog, I hope that it doesnt disappoint me as much as this one. I mean, I know it was my choice to read, but I actually thought youd have something interesting to say. All I hear is a bunch of whining about something that you could fix if you werent too busy looking for attention.

  16. I discovered your blog site on google and check a few of your early posts. Continue to keep up the very good operate. I just additional up your RSS feed to my MSN News Reader. Seeking forward to reading more from you later on!?

  17. There are some interesting points in time in this article but I don?t know if I see all of them center to heart. There is some validity but I will take hold opinion until I look into it further. Good article , thanks and we want more! Added to FeedBurner as well

  18. 同样身为联合国开发计划署亲善大使的前法国国家队队长齐达内(ZinedineZidane)和巴西传奇前锋罗纳尔多(Ronaldo),将和效力于英格兰超级足球联赛劲旅切尔西(Chelsea)的象牙海岸籍前锋“魔兽”德罗巴(DidierDrogba)、退役荷兰中场席多夫(ClarenceSeedorf)及前巴西国家队长卡富(Cafu)共同组队。

  19. There are certainly a lot of details like that to take into consideration. That is a great point to bring up. I offer the thoughts above as general inspiration but clearly there are questions like the one you bring up where the most important thing will be working in honest good faith. I don?t know if best practices have emerged around things like that, but I am sure that your job is clearly identified as a fair game. Both boys and girls feel the impact of just a moment?s pleasure, for the rest of their lives.

  20. 香港明报报导,德国世界杯随着意大利击败法国而曲终人散,然而决赛延长赛下半场,法国球王席丹突然向意大利后卫(马特拉吉)施展(铁头功)导致被…意大利足球队后卫马特拉吉今天否认报导所说,他在周日世足决赛遭法国队长席丹以头锤顶撞倒地之前,曾将席丹(齐达内)称为“卑鄙的恐怖份子”。

  21. Can I just say what a relief to find someone who actually knows what theyre talking about on the internet. You definitely know how to bring an issue to light and make it important. More people need to read this and understand this side of the story. I cant believe youre not more popular because you definitely have the gift.

  22. (塞尔吉奥)新浪体育公众号24小时滚动播报最新体育资讯、趣闻和视频,更多福利扫描二维码关注(sinasports)虎扑5月2日讯皇马主帅齐达内在球队淘汰拜仁的比赛后评价了这场比赛:这是一场疯狂的比赛,球迷们一定会很喜欢。

  23. 世界杯足球赛冠军战赏给法国巨星席丹红牌,使席丹草草退休的阿根廷籍主审艾里松多,今天在觐见总统基西纳时,将当时出示的红牌送给基西纳当作礼物…法国足球代表队队长席丹在世界杯足球赛决赛头槌攻击意大利后卫,轰动全世界。

Leave a Reply